International Journal of Theoretical and Mathematical Physics

p-ISSN: 2167-6844    e-ISSN: 2167-6852

2018;  8(4): 89-93

doi:10.5923/j.ijtmp.20180804.02

 

Dirac Equation in SO(6) Real Representation Leading to Four Triplets

Doron Kwiat

17/2 Erez Street, Mazkeret Batyia, Israel

Correspondence to: Doron Kwiat , 17/2 Erez Street, Mazkeret Batyia, Israel.

Email:

Copyright © 2018 The Author(s). Published by Scientific & Academic Publishing.

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY).
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Abstract

Introducing four 6x6 Lorentz invariant gamma matrices removes asymmetry in the three spatial coordinates of Dirac equation. Use of the SO(6) representation provides 12 real wave functions which are divided into 4 groups of triplets. These 4 groups interact with each other and each element of a triplet satisfies the Klein-Gordon equation.

Keywords: Dirac Equation, 6x6 Gamma Matrices, Triplets

Cite this paper: Doron Kwiat , Dirac Equation in SO(6) Real Representation Leading to Four Triplets, International Journal of Theoretical and Mathematical Physics, Vol. 8 No. 4, 2018, pp. 89-93. doi: 10.5923/j.ijtmp.20180804.02.

1. Introduction

Recently, it was shown [1] that a single non-relativistic Schrödinger equation is a description of a single massive particle, made up of two coupled strings. One may project from this on the relativistic Dirac equation [2], describing a free Fermion of mass m:
(1)
One may separate the complex wave function into its real and imaginary parts [3]
(2)
and by using them in the Dirac equation, one will get two separate equations where imaginary and real parts have been separated.
This same procedure can be applied to any quantum field Lagrangian, resulting (at the cost of doubling the number of equations) in separation of the equations to real wave functions.
These wave functions may be interpreted as coupled strings.
In Dirac equation (1), the four matrices are:
(3)
where I2 is the 2x2 unit matrix and the Pauli 2x2 matrices.
(4)
Of these matrices, only has imaginary components and it can be replaced by writing
where and therefore
(5)
Decomposing into where and are real, the Dirac equation becomes two separate equations,
(6)
(7)
There are now 8 real wave functions instead of 4 in the complex presentation. Notice the asymmetry of the y-component in Eqs. (6,7) due to the complex nature of Pauli's

2. Changing Dirac 4x4 γ Matrices to 6x6 Representation

To move from classical QM to relativistic QM, Dirac came with the idea of taking the square root of the wave operator thus, he suggested:
(8)
and in order to get all the cross-terms such as to vanish, one must assume
(9)
Or, if represent the A, B, C, D terms, can be written in a compact form
(10)
These conditions are met if A, B, C and D are matrices, with the implication that the wave function has multiple components. This immediately explained the appearance of two-component wave functions in Pauli's theory of spin. The most direct suggestion would be to have A, B, C and D as 4x4 matrices. This is done in combinations of 2x2 Pauli matrices, in such a way that will obey the constrains. This leads to the assertion to be made, that is a 4-vector of complex wave functions.
In a 3+1 world, is a 4x4 matrix, so the dimension of the A, B, C and D are 4x4 matrices. However in an N-dimensional world, one needs NxN matrices [4], with N>=4, to set up a system with the properties required. In Dirac's original work N=4, so the wave function had four components, not two, as in the Pauli theory, or one, as in the bare Schrödinger theory. When looking into the initial development strategy of Dirac, his initial demand was to create an equation with first derivatives:
(11)
Since it originated in the Klein-Gordon [5] equation, which by itself originated from Schrödinger equation, it was assumed there that is complex and therefore can be presented as a 2-vector of two complex wave functions.
In this work, instead of using the conventional 4x4 matrices (A, B, C and D) as introduced by Dirac, a set of four 6x6 matrices , matrices acting on a complex 6-vector are introduced, which satisfy Eq. (11), and the constrains in Eq. (10).
This is equivalent to changing from complex representation of rotations in to real rotations [7] in . Since SO(3) is homomorphic with SU(2), the rotations in of a 3-component real wave vector is equivalent to a rotation in of a 2-component complex wave vector.
Instead of using Pauli's 2x2 matrices, one may use the 3x3 matrix presentations of angular momentum generators and of the rotation group SO(3).
Using and outer multiplications with and with and to define the matrices, satisfying the requirements on A, B, C and D according to Eq. (11).
Thus:
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
These matrices replace the 4x4 matrices in Dirac 4x4 equation to introduce the Dirac 6x6 equation:
(16)
where is now a complex 6-vector
(17)
and where , are four real 6x6 matrices, satisfying the Clifford requirement:
(18)
It has now 12 real wave functions (6 and 6) instead of 8 (4 and 4).

3. Lorentz Covariance of the 6x6 χ Matrices

To prove Lorentz covariance of the Dirac equation, with the 4x4 gamma matrices, one requires the existence of a 4x4 transformation matrix S, such that under a Lorentz transformation.
Suppose that
under
Obviously, if such transformation S exists, the 4x4 Dirac equation is Lorentz invariant.
By assuming an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation
(19)
( are real numerical coefficients, independent of x), one can write for S
(20)
Where are 4x4 matrices that satisfy
(21)
This derivation of the Lorentz group representation of 4x4 matrix generators is based on the relationship
Since satisfies the same constraints as we conclude that there exist 6x6 generators of the S transformation of the Dirac 6x6 representation, and hence Dirac's 6x6 representation, Eq. (16), is Lorentz covariant.
The Dirac matrices must satisfy the canonical anti-commutation relation
The above definition corresponds to the so-called "chiral basis," where Dirac matrices are block anti-diagonal.
Other bases are possible, and are related to the chiral basis by rotations. The Dirac matrices generate a Euclidean Clifford algebra [6].
N-dimensional gamma matrices are a generalization of the four-dimensional Gamma matrices of Dirac to arbitrary dimension N. They are utilized in relativistic invariant wave equations for fermions (such as spinors) in arbitrary space-time dimensions, notably in string theory and supergravity.
Consider a d-dimensional space-time, with a flat Minkowski metric where standard Dirac matrices correspond to taking d = N = 4.
The higher dimension matrices are a d-long sequence of complex N×N matrices (i =0, … d-1) which satisfy the anticommutator relation from the Clifford algebra generating a representation for this algebra
where is the N dimensional identity matrix. (The spinors acted on by these matrices have N components in d dimensions.) Such a sequence exists for all values of d.
In this work, matrices are real, with N=6 and d=4.
Thus, , though without the restriction of

4. Solution Leading to Triplets

To solve Eq. (16) split the 6-vector into real and imaginary parts (both and are real 6-vectors)
Further split the 6-vectors into two triplets (3-vectors) each:
(22)
(23)
So that and are 4 different real triplets.
Substituting Eqs. (22,23) in Dirac's 6x6 representation Eq. (16) gives 4 differential equations with 12 unknowns (4 triplets) parameters:
(24)
(25)
(26)
(27)
Where stands for , a 3x3 operator.
Applying time derivative to Eqs. (24-27) gives
(28)
(29)
(30)
(31)
Define two matrices:
(32)
The differential equations (24-27) and (28-31) can be written as
(33)
(34)
Which combines to:
(35)
We notice that and and also . Thus:
(36)
(37)
(38)
(39)
Dirac equation has become symmetrical in x, y and z. The spatial asymmetry has been removed.
Second, Dirac equation Eq. (16) turned into four real, apparently uncoupled (3-vectors) triplets. Each triplet satisfies Klein-Gordon [5] wave equation (Eqs. (36-39)), with well-known solutions.
However, when introducing in Eq. (16)
one can separate it into the real and imaginary parts and obtain:
(40)
(41)
where by definition: is a 6x6 matrix operator, and
Equations (40) and (41) are two differential equations of first order and show that the and sextets (6-vectors) are coupled to each other.
In fact, one can say that there are 12 real wave functions. Each satisfies the Klein-Gordon equation individually and independently. These 12 real wave functions are combined into two sextets, and each sextet is made of two triplets. Altogether there are four triplets.
Looking for instance at Eqs. (24-27), the time derivative of one triplet, depends on the spatial derivatives of the second triplet and on a mass-proportional term of the third triplet. This coupling mechanism exists amongst the other triplets combinations in turn (see Figure 1). The four triplets and , are denoted here by A B C and D. Each triplet's time derivative is coupled to the spatial derivative of two other triplets and proportional by a factor to the fourth triplet entity, at a time. This coupling is changing between the 4 entities so that all four combinations are allowed. Each component of the three components the triplets are made of, satisfies the Klein-Gordon wave equation.
Figure 1. The quartet of and entities. Each entity (denoted here by A B C and D) is a 3-vector. Each single entity time derivative is coupled to the spatial derivative of two other entities and proportional by a factor to the fourth entity, at a time. This coupling is changing between the 4 entities so that all four combinations are allowed
The and matrices are responsible for the exchanges between the triplets
Q exchanges and R exchanges .
Therefore, the term will affect the lower triplet pair (C and D) by exchange as well as by mass change, whereas the term will only cause an exchange in the upper triplet pair (A and B).
To summarize, the following notations are introduced:
Then, combining Eqs. (22-23,24-27,40-43) gives
This form helps in the interpretation of how the real and imaginary parts of the Dirac fields interact.

5. Electromagnetic Field

Dirac 6x6 equation Eq. (16) in the presence of electromagnetic field becomes
(42)
Hence, Eq. (66) becomes
(43)
Eq. (43) is similar to Eq. (33) except for the term
added to the l.h.s.
Thus, for the very weak field approximation, , there will be no exchange between the triplets more than in the case without EM field.
The solution of Eq. (43) will be approximately similar to that of Eq. (66), except for an interaction term

6. A Vibrating Membrane [8, 9]

Assuming polar symmetry, Eqs. (36-39) become
(44)
Where the y coordinate is the cylinder's main axis and x and z are in the plane perpendicular to the y-axis (see Figure 2).
Figure 2. A membrane in x, y, z coordinate system
The solution to Eq. (44) is
(45)
where knm is the mth root of
Defining
(46)
and
(47)
One can write
(48)
Assuming spherical symmetry, Dirac equation to spherical coordinates Eqs. (36-39), become
(49)
The most general solution is then
(50)
Where and are constants to be determined by the boundary conditions.
The time dependency is given by
The spherical dependency is given by the spherical harmonic functions, with the Legendre polynomials and normalization constants
Since by boundary conditions for one must have except for
Since by boundary conditions is finite for , one must have .
The solution is then
(51)
One may interpret the wave functions in Dirac equation, as describing 4 independent membranes 1. Each two membranes are coupled into a two-folded membrane, closed at their common circular edges.
The membranes can be at different modes of vibrations (see Figure 3).
Figure 3. A Dirac membrane modes

7. Conclusions

Dirac equation can be represented in a real 6x6 matrix form. This is done by changing the wave function to a 6-vector instead of a 4-vector and replacing Dirac's 4x4 matrices, by four 6x6 matrices.
This results in two similar Klein-Gordon equations, acting on two independent real wave functions, represented by two 6-vectors.
Dirac's equation, represents then a system of four (a quartet) coupled triplets A, B, C and D. Each of this quartet has an internal structure (triplet) of 3 sub-entities. The 4 members of the quartet, are coupled and interact with each other. Each member of the triplets satisfies Klein-Gordon equation.
The solution to Dirac equation is made up of 12 real wave functions (four triplets).
The quartet members are coupled in pairs A and B, and C and D. The spatial derivative of A affects the time derivative of B and vice versa. The spatial derivative of C affects the time derivative of D and vice versa. Yet, when second order time derivatives are considered, the quartet members act as 4 independent entities obeying KG wave equations independent of each other.

References

[1]  D Kwiat, The Schrödinger Equation and Asymptotic Strings, International Journal of Theoretical and Mathematical Physics, Vol 8 (3), pp 71-77, 2018.
[2]  Dirac, P. A. M., "The Quantum Theory of the Electron", Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences. 117 (778): 610. 1928.
[3]  B Hatfield, Quantum Field Theory of Point Particles and Strings. Mathematical Physics Research, CRC Press, 2018, Taylor & Francis Group.
[4]  Andrzej Trautman, Uniwersytet Warszawski, Clifford Algebras and their representations, Warszawa, Poland Published in: Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics, Oxford: Elsevier, 2006, vol. 1, pages 518–530.
[5]  O. Klein, Z. Fur Physik 37 895 (1926); O. Klein, Nature 118 516 (1926).
[6]  W. K. Clifford, “On the classification of geometric algebras”, in Mathematical Papers (1882), Tucker R., (Ed.), Macmillian, London, pp. 397–401.
[7]  H. Goldstein, Classical Mechanics, 2nd edition, Addison Wesley Publishing, Chapter 4 "The kinematics of rigid body rotations", 1980.
[8]  L. W. Casperson and M-A. Nicolet, Vibrations of a Circular Membrane, American Journal of Physics 36, 669 (1968).
[9]  Daria Apushkinskaya, The Vibrating Drumhead (Wave Equation in Polar Coordinates), PDE and Boundary-Value Problems Winter Term 2014/2015, Saarland University, lecture 16. https://www.math.uni-sb.de/ag/fuchs/PDE14-15/pde14-15-lecture-16.pdf, Leonard Susskind, Art Friedman, "Quantum Mechanics: The Theoretical Minimum", Penguin, Published 30th April 2015.