International Journal of Materials Engineering
p-ISSN: 2166-5389 e-ISSN: 2166-5400
2012; 2(6): 90-104
doi: 10.5923/j.ijme.20120206.04
D. Ouinas1, A. Flliti1, M. Sahnoun1, S. Benbarek2, N. Taghezout3
1Laboratoire de modélisation numérique et expérimentale des phénomènes mécaniques, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University Abdelhamid Ibn Badis, Mostaganem, 27000, Algeria
2LECM, Department of Mechanics, Faculty of Engineering, University of Sidi-BelAbbes, 22000, Algeria
3Department of Computer Science, University of Es-Senia Oran, BP 1524, El-M' Naouer, 31000, Oran, Algeria
Correspondence to: D. Ouinas, Laboratoire de modélisation numérique et expérimentale des phénomènes mécaniques, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University Abdelhamid Ibn Badis, Mostaganem, 27000, Algeria.
| Email: | ![]() |
Copyright © 2012 Scientific & Academic Publishing. All Rights Reserved.
In this work, the finite element method is used to analyze the behavior of the crack emanating from a microvoid in acetabular cement mantle by computing the stress intensity factor. A simple 2D multilayer model developed by Benbarek et al.[1] to reproduce the stress distributions in the cement mantle has been used. To provide the place of birth of the crack, the stress distribution around the microvoid is determined in several positions for three different loads. The effect of axial and radial displacement of the microvoid in the cement is highlighted. The results indicate that the stress distribution
and
induced in the cement around the microvoid are not homogeneous and this, whatever its position. In addition, there is a large birth risk of cracks in several radial directions depending on the position of the microvoid in the cement mantle. The crack can be triggered in several directions in mode I or mode II, while the mixed mode is dominant. The KI and KII SIF varies according to the position of the microcrack and the microvoid in the cement. They increase proportionally with the increase of the weight of the patient. It should be noted that the KI SIF are two times higher than the SIF KII. The maxima of the KI SIF are obtained for the position of the microvoid α = 100° and θ = 45° of the microcrack and the risk of the propagation of the microcrack is very important for this orientation.
Keywords: Bone cement, Acetabulum, Microvoid, Microcracks, Stress Intensity Factors, Finite Element Analysis
Cite this paper: D. Ouinas, A. Flliti, M. Sahnoun, S. Benbarek, N. Taghezout, "Fracture Behavior of the Cement Mantle of Reconstructed Acetabulum in the Presence of a Microcrack Emanating from a Microvoid", International Journal of Materials Engineering, Vol. 2 No. 6, 2012, pp. 90-104. doi: 10.5923/j.ijme.20120206.04.
![]() | Figure 1. Composition of the acetabulum[24] |
![]() | Figure 2. Geometrical model Mesh |
![]() | Figure 3. Load model |
are taken at 0°, 20°, 40°, 70°, 90°, 100°, 120°, 150° and 170°. For each angle
of the microvoid nine axial positions are taken from the cup-cement interface head to the cement-bone interface-subchondral bone (compact bone beneath the cartilage resistant). The Von Mises stresses are plotted for three load cases, a weight of 70kg, 140kg and 210kg. The normal weight of the patient can be multiplied according to these activities, in walk state, rising and descending stairs.In Figures 4.1-4.3 we see that the maximum Von Mises stresses are obtained in the middle positions of the cavity. They are becoming increasingly important with the importance of patient weight.It is clear that the stress distribution is not uniform around the microvoid. We note several peaks in each radial position of the microvoid. All these stresses are due to the compression effect produced by the weight of the patient. At the radial position corresponds to
the maximum stress at the interface is cup-cement of the order of 20MPa and the bone-cement interface subchondral is of the order of 35MPa. The first interface to the second interface stress changes from single to double, this shows that when the microvoid is close to the bone-cement interface subchondral interaction effect is much larger than when it is close to the interface head cup-cement. The maximum stresses in the microvoid near the interface cement / bone sub-chonral into position
are of the order of 35MPa, 70MPa and 140MPa, respectively for the weight of 70kg, 140kg and 210kg. This shows the effect of the interaction between the microvoid and the interface. In these three cases the maximum stress exceeds the tensile failure, which shows the severity of the defect position in the cement. In addition, depending on the axial position of the microvoid, the constraints become important. From the position P1 where the cavity is close to the cup-cement interface, the maximum stress increases progressively to approach the interface cement-subchondral bone. This finding is significant regardless of the radial position of the microvoid. The stress levels at the radial position of microvoid
are respectively 7, 3, 5.2, 1.75, 3, 9, 30 times higher than the radial positions
and
respectively. This shows that if the microvoid is in positions
it presents a high risk compared to other radial positionsExcept for the radial position at
, the curves show four zones of stress concentration. The areas characterized by the highest concentrations are obtained at positions
and
, that is to say the bottom of the microvoid. The other two zones are at positions
and
. It should be noted that when the microvoid is in radial positions at
, the Von Mises stresses are very low compared to other positions. At the radial position
the maximum stresses are very important and this is the fact that the microvoid is located between the cup and the cortical bone.
on the Contour of the Microvoid
are null whatever the applied load (70kg, 140kg and 210kg). The curves are antisymmetric with respect to the x axis of the cavity that is to say with respect 180 °. The maximum stresses are obtained for the position of the cavity at 100°. At 120°, the stresses are similar to those marked 100°. The two peaks maximum stress positive are at 60 ° and 240 ° and the two peaks of the compressive stress are in 120 ° and 300 °.The maximum compression stresses are important for the position of the microvoid null, this is due to the edge effect. Such a position of the microvoid in cement, fact of increasing strongly the risk of damage. Thus, when the patient's weight exceeds 100kg, any position of the microvoid can lead to rupture of the cement in the first cycles of activity and therefore to the destruction of the hip prosthesis.
on the Contour of the Microvoid
on the contour of the microvoid for different positions in cement. It is clear that gaits are antisymmetric with respect to 180°. For all cases, the tensile stresses in the near vicinity of the microvoid are small compared with the compressive stresses at the position
When the weight P=70 kg, the maximum compressive stress
is about four times lower of the compression fracture limit, while the traction is three times lower, which shows that they are relatively low. By against, a weight of 140kg and the position of the microvoid to 100°, the constraints tend to the tensile strength limit to angles 30° and 210°. The stress
greatly exceeds the strength in tension and compression. In this case, the cement is almost fragmented in tension or compression depending on the position of the microvoid in the binder.
on the Contour of the Microvoid
and
the tangential stresses are low to create a microcrack mode II.
and in the interval varying from 90° to 120° in both interfaces.The first peak is obtained at 0° and the second at 100° for the two interfaces of the cement. In this case, the Von Mises stresses are almost three times less to tensile strength stress. It should be noted that if a microvoid is in these two areas of peak stress, the defect will quadruplicate the stress and therefore present a high risk of microcrack initiation, and the likelihood of its spread is high. The Von Mises stresses are higher in the cup/cement interface that in the cement interface-subchondral bone and it explains that the cement is a stress absorber. If a cavity is close to the interface, the stresses in the interface and the cavity will be increased as a result of interaction and therefore the risk of damage is major. This behavior shows that the existence of the microvoid is a source of increasing stress concentrations and consequently the risk of loosening of the prosthesis
and
The positions of the maximum stresses on the contour of the microvoid whose a microcrack is susceptible to propagate are the angles
and
respectively
and
According to figures 9.1-9.6, we find that the stress intensity factors KI and KII will vary as a function of the increase in the length of the microcrack emanating from the microvoid. This variation is more marked with increasing of patient weight. The stress intensity factors KI for the positions of the microvoid 40° are positive and for positions 0° are negative. While KII SIF are negatives whatever the microvoid position. We note that the SIF KI and KII obtained for the position
of the microvoid are much larger in absolute value compared to other positions, showing that the birth of a microcrack emanating from a cavity at an angle
constitute a high risk of rupture compared with other positions. This is due to the edge effect. The KII SIF is almost ten times smaller than the KI except for the case of load 70kg, where it is almost negligible for large microcracks. In position
, the KI SIF shows significant positive values that can cause rupture of the cement easily. This microvoid position affects significantly the bone-cement fracture toughness, which controls the failure process at the interfaces.In Figure 10 we present the Von Mises stress levels for four different orientations
and
the microvoid in cement. It shows the mapping stress of the microcrack tip emanating from the microvoid located in the bone cement. It is clear that stresses vary depending on the microvoid position. In Figures 11.1-11.6 we plotted the variation of KI and KII SIF as a function of the microcrack length in the second position containing the maximum stresses on the Von Mises contour of the microvoid to the angles
and
respectively
and
It is clear that the SIF of oriented microcrack in the second position are low compared to the first position. In this case the KII SIF changes sign, it is positive for 
. The same behavior has been marked when the microvoid is at the position α = 120°. If the microvoid is at the position α = 40°, the microcrack is susceptible to propagate in pure mode I at θ = 135° or at θ = 335° or pure mode II at θ = 20° or θ = 170°. And if it is at 0°, the SIF KI reaches its maximum negative at 0 ° and 335 ° for the SIF KII.![]() | Figure 4. Variation of Von Mises stress on the microvoid contour located in the bone cement in different positions and different loads. |
![]() | Figure 5. Variation in the stress on the microvoid contour |
![]() | Figure 6. Variation in the stress on the microvoid contour |
![]() | Figure 7. Variation in the stress on the microvoid contour |
![]() | Figure 8. Variation of Von Mises stress contours on the bone cement |
![]() | Figure 9. Variation of KI and KII SIF vs. microcrack length emanating from the microcavity in the bone cement (position 1) |
![]() | Figure 10. Variation of stress levels at the microcrack-tip and the microcavity located in the bone cement |
![]() | Figure 11. Variation of KI and KII SIF vs. microcrack length emanating from the microcavity in the bone cement (position 2) |
![]() | Figure 12. Variation of SIF of microcrack emanating from a microcavity according to the angle![]() |
,
and
in the cement around the microvoid are not homogeneous and this whatever of its position. The maximum stresses
are obtained respectively for the positions of the cavity at 100° and 120°.→The stresses are null at positions 0° and 180°. Two peaks of maximum stress are positives at 60° and 240° and two peaks of the compressive stress are at 120° to 300°. The
stresses are antisymmetric with respect to 180 °. For all cases, the tensile stresses at the near vicinity of the microvoid are small compared with the compressive stresses at the position of
The variation of shear stress on the contour of the microvoid is periodic. However, the highest compression stresses are obtained for the position of the cavity at 100 ° and are relatively low in comparison with the stresses
and
→The presence of the cavity has an effect on the variation of the stress at the interfaces cement-cup and cement-subchondral bone. The Von Mises stress is maximum in the most stressed areas are in the position
and in the interval ranging from 90° to 120° in both interfaces. Two peaks of maximum stress: at 0° and 100°. The Von Mises stresse are higher in the interface cement-cup that in cement-subchondral bone interface.→If a cavity is close to the interface, the stress in the interface and the cavity will be amplified under the interaction effect and therefore the risk of damage is major. This behavior shows that the existence of the microvoid in the cement will be a source of multiplication of stress concentrations and therefore the loosening of the prosthesis.→The risk of the initiation of cracks in the cement is important when the microvoid is close to the bone-cement interface. The amplification is greater when it is at an angle
→The SIFs KI and KII increase with increasing of the microcrack length emanating from the microvoid. This increase is even more marked with increasing patient weight. The SIF KI for the positions of the microvoid
are positive and for positions
are negative. The risk is major with the presence of two cracks.| [1] | S. Benbarek, B. Bachir Bouiadjra, T. Achour, M. Belhouari, B. Serier. Finite element analysis of the behaviour of crack emanating from microvoid in cement of reconstructed acetabulum. Materials Science and Engineering A 457 (2007) 385–391. |
| [2] | J.CHARNLEY. Low friction arthroplasty of the hip. Theory and practice. Springer Verlag, Berlin, Berlin, 1979 |
| [3] | G. Bergmann, F. Graichen, A. Rohlmann. Hip joint loading during walking and running, measured in two patients. J Biomechanics, 1993, vol. 26 no.8 p969–90 |
| [4] | Berme N, Paul JP. Load actions transmitted by implants. J Biomed Eng. 1979, 1 p 268–272 |
| [5] | D. Ouinas, B. Bachir Bouiadjra, B. Serier, N. Benderdouche, A. Ouinas, Numerical analysis of Brazilian bioceramic discs under diametrical compression loading. Computational Materials Science 45 (2009) 443–448. |
| [6] | SR. Goldring, AL. Schiller, M. Roelke, CM. Rourke, DO. O’Connor, WH. Harris. Formation of a synovial-like membrane at the bonecement interface. J Bone J Surg;A65:575-84, 1983. |
| [7] | M. Jasty, WJ. Malony, CR. Bragdon, DO. O'Connor, T. Haire, WH. Harris. The initiation of failure in cemented femoral components of hip arthroplasties”. J Bone Joint Surg;B73: 551-8, 1991. |
| [8] | N. Passuti, F. Gouin. Les ciments aux antibiotiques dans la chirurgie orthopédique. Revue du rhumatisme 70: 371–378, 2003. |
| [9] | RSM. LING, JC. LEE. Porosity reduction in acrylic cement is clinically irrelevant. Clinical Orthopedics, 355, 249-253, 1998. |
| [10] | DW. Janssen, J. Stolk, N. Verdonschot. Why would cement porosity reduction be clinically irrelevant, while experimental data show the contrary? 50th Annual Meeting of the Orthopaedic Research Society. San Francisco, USA, p 3, 2004. |
| [11] | W. Macaulay, CW. DiGiovanni, A. Restrepo, KJ. Saleh, H. Walsh, LS. Crossett, MG. Peterson,S. Li, EA. Salvati. Differences in bone-cement porosity by vacuum mixing, centrifugation, and hand mixing. J Arthroplasty 2002; 17:569–575 |
| [12] | U. Linden, J. Gillquist. Air inclusion in bone cement. Importance of the mixing technique. Clin Orthop 1989; 247:148–51 |
| [13] | JS. Wang, F. Kjellson. Bone cement porosity in Vacuum Mixing system. In: Walenkamp GHIM, Murray DW (eds) Bone cements and Cementing technique. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York Tokyo, pp 81–95, 2001. |
| [14] | S. Wang, H. Franzén, E. Jonsson, L. Lidgren. Porosity of bone cement reduced by mixing and collecting under vacuum. Acta Orthop Scand 64(2):143–46, 1993. |
| [15] | S. Wang, S. Toksvig-Larsen, P. Müller-Wille, H. Franzén. Is their any difference between vacuum mixing systems in reducing bone cement porosity? J Biomed Mater Res (Applied Biomaterials) 33:115–19, 1996. |
| [16] | WP. Yau, TP. Ng, KY. Chiu, KC. Poon, WY. Ho, DK .Luk. The performance of three vacuum mixing cement guns- acomparison of the fatigue properties of Simplex P cement. International Orthopaedics 25:290–293, 2001. |
| [17] | JM. Wilkinson, R. Eveleigh, AJ. Hamer, A. Milne, AW. Miles, I. Stockely. Effect of mixing technique on the properties of acrylic bone cement. J Arthroplasty 15:663–7, 2000. |
| [18] | B. Serier, B. Bachir Bouiadjra *, S. Benbarek, T. Achour. Analysis of the effect of the forces during gait on the fracture behaviour in cement of reconstructed acetabulum. Computational Materials Science 46 (2009) 267–274. |
| [19] | B. Bachir Bouiadjra, A. Belarbi, S. Benbarek, T. Achour, B. Serier. FE analysis of the behaviour of microcracks in the cement mantle of reconstructed acetabulum in the total hip prosthesis. Computational Materials Science 40 (2007) 485–491. |
| [20] | T. Achour, M.S.H. Tabeti, M.M. Bouziane, S. Benbarek, B. Bachir Bouiadjra, A. Mankour. Finite element analysis of interfacial crack behaviour in cemented total hip arthroplasty. Computational Materials Science 47 (2010) 672–677 |
| [21] | A. Flitti, D. Ouinas, B. Bachir Bouiadjra, N. Benderdouche. Effect of the crack position in the cement mantle on the fracture behavior of the total hip prosthesis. Computational Materials Science 49 (2010) 598–602 |
| [22] | M.M. Bouziane, B. Bachir Bouiadjra, S. Benbarek, M.S.H. Tabeti, T. Achour. Finite element analysis of the behaviour of microvoids in the cement mantle of cemented hip stem: Static and dynamic analysis. Materials and Design 31 (2010) 545–550. |
| [23] | J. Tong, K.Y. Wong, Mixed Mode Fracture in Reconstructed Acetabulum, Department of Mechanical and design Engineering, University of Portsmouth, Anglesea road, Portsmouth, PO1 3 DJ, UK. |
| [24] | Christipher, Peter, Ken, Bachus, Marcis, Craig, Higginbotham, J. Arthroplasty, 16 (2001) 2. |
| [25] | G. Bergmann, F. Graichen, A. Rohlmann. Hip Joint Loading During Walking and Running, Measured in Two Patients. J. Biomech. 1993;26(8):969–990. |
| [26] | A. Phillips, Finite Element Analysis of the Acetabulum after Impacting Grafting, The University of Edinburgh, School of civil and environmental Engineering. Crew Building, Kings Buildings, Edinburgh EH93JN. |
| [27] | C. Li, C. Granger, H. Del Schutte Jr., S.B. Biggers Jr., J.M. Kennedy, R.A. Latour, Failure Analysis of Composite Femoral Components for Hip Arthroplastiy, Department of Bioengineering and Department of Mechanical Engineering, Clemson University, Clemson,SC. |
| [28] | C. Delaunay, Prothèse totale de Charnley o`u en est aujourd’hui le «le Gold-Standard» de l’arthoplastie primaire de hanche, Clinique de l’Yvette – 91160 longjumeau. |
| [29] | D. Foucat. Effets de la présence d’un alliage métallique au sein du ciment de scellement des cupules des prothèses totale de hanche. Etude mécanique et thermique. Thèse doctorat-2003.ULP_ INSA Strasbourg – ANGES – URS. |
| [30] | K. Sorensen, Abaqus user manual 6.9.11. |
| [31] | G. Bergmann, F. Graichen, A. Rohlmann. Hip joint loading during walking and running, measured in two patients. Journal of Biomechanics, 1993, Vol. 26, 969-990. |