American Journal of Mathematics and Statistics
p-ISSN: 2162-948X e-ISSN: 2162-8475
2015; 5(1): 15-23
doi:10.5923/j.ajms.20150501.03

Udoy S. Basak 1, Jannatun Nayeem 2, Chandra N. Podder 3
1Department of Mathematics, Pabna University of Science & Technology, Bangladesh
2Department of Arts and Sciences, AUST, Dhaka, Bangladesh
3Department of Mathematics, University of Dhaka, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Correspondence to: Jannatun Nayeem , Department of Arts and Sciences, AUST, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
| Email: |  | 
Copyright © 2015 Scientific & Academic Publishing. All Rights Reserved.
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY). 
                    	http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
                    	
                        Mathematical models and underlying transmission mechanism of the HIV and HSV-2 can help the scientists and medical researchers to understand and anticipate their spread in different populations. Present study fitted mathematical models, which exhibit two equilibrium points, namely, the disease free equilibrium point and the endemic equilibrium point. It is found that if the basic reproduction number  the disease free equilibrium point is locally asymptotically stable which may not be globally asymptotically stable when
 the disease free equilibrium point is locally asymptotically stable which may not be globally asymptotically stable when  If
 If  the endemic equilibrium exists which is locally asymptotically stable under some conditions. Numerical simulations suggest that the individual experiencing incident HSV-2 infections are at a risk of HIV acquisition, compared with individuals not infected with HSV-2 or who have prevalent HSV-2 infection. Thus the reduction of the effective contact rate of HSV-2 can reduce the disease burden of co-infection. Controlling the transfer rate from HIV class to the AIDS class disease elimination is feasible. Controlling the transfer rate from the HSV-2 exposed class to the HSV-2 infected class disease control is also feasible.
 the endemic equilibrium exists which is locally asymptotically stable under some conditions. Numerical simulations suggest that the individual experiencing incident HSV-2 infections are at a risk of HIV acquisition, compared with individuals not infected with HSV-2 or who have prevalent HSV-2 infection. Thus the reduction of the effective contact rate of HSV-2 can reduce the disease burden of co-infection. Controlling the transfer rate from HIV class to the AIDS class disease elimination is feasible. Controlling the transfer rate from the HSV-2 exposed class to the HSV-2 infected class disease control is also feasible.
                    
Keywords: Equilibrium, Local and Global Stability, Endemic Equilibrium
Cite this paper: Udoy S. Basak , Jannatun Nayeem , Chandra N. Podder , Mathematical Study of HIV and HSV-2 Co-Infection, American Journal of Mathematics and Statistics, Vol. 5 No. 1, 2015, pp. 15-23. doi: 10.5923/j.ajms.20150501.03.
 cells), macrophages and dendrite cells. HIV infection leads to low levels of
 cells), macrophages and dendrite cells. HIV infection leads to low levels of  cells through a number of mechanisms including: apoptosis of uninfected by stance cells, direct viral killing of infected cells, and killing of infected
 cells through a number of mechanisms including: apoptosis of uninfected by stance cells, direct viral killing of infected cells, and killing of infected  cells by
 cells by  cytotoxic lymphocytes that recognize infected cells. When
 cytotoxic lymphocytes that recognize infected cells. When  cell numbers decline below a critical level, cell-mediated immunity is lost, and the body becomes progressively more susceptible to opportunistic infections [4].Of the 2732 individuals enrolled, 2260 were male, 463 were female and 9 of them were eunuchs. The prevalence of HSV-2 at enrolment was 43%. The HSV-2 incidence 11.4% and the HIV incidence were 5.9% cases per year [4]. The HIV incidence was 3.6% per years among persons without evidence of HSV-2 infection, 7.5% per years among persons with prevalent or remote incident HSV-2 infection and  22.6% per year among persons with recent incident HSV-2 infection [4].The interaction between clinically apparent or self reported genital ulcer disease and HSV-2 sero-status was also investigated. Of the 217 individuals with serologic evidence of incident HSV-2 infection, 51 (23%) had a genital lesion documented at the same visit at which sero-conversion was demonstrated. Using a proportional hazards model, the investigators found that the presence of asymptotic prevalent HSV-2 infection conferred an adjusted hazard ratio for HIV infection of 2.14 (compared with no genital ulceration and negative results of serologic testing for HSV-2). Symptomatic prevalent HSV-2 infection conferred an adjusted hazard ratio of 5.06.In short, this demonstrated that individuals experiencing incident HSV-2 infections are at the greatest risk of HIV acquisition, compared with individuals not infected with HSV-2 or who have prevalent HSV-2 infection. The individuals with serologic evidence of recent incident HSV-2 infection had the highest HIV incidence, illustrating that recent infection with HSV-2 is independently associated with HIV acquisition [4].Dr. Balfour pointed out that some recent in vitro studies have helped to explain the association between HSV-2 and HIV [4]. First, some studies have demonstrated that HSV-2 infection may increase the risk of HIV acquisition through the influx of susceptible, host
 cell numbers decline below a critical level, cell-mediated immunity is lost, and the body becomes progressively more susceptible to opportunistic infections [4].Of the 2732 individuals enrolled, 2260 were male, 463 were female and 9 of them were eunuchs. The prevalence of HSV-2 at enrolment was 43%. The HSV-2 incidence 11.4% and the HIV incidence were 5.9% cases per year [4]. The HIV incidence was 3.6% per years among persons without evidence of HSV-2 infection, 7.5% per years among persons with prevalent or remote incident HSV-2 infection and  22.6% per year among persons with recent incident HSV-2 infection [4].The interaction between clinically apparent or self reported genital ulcer disease and HSV-2 sero-status was also investigated. Of the 217 individuals with serologic evidence of incident HSV-2 infection, 51 (23%) had a genital lesion documented at the same visit at which sero-conversion was demonstrated. Using a proportional hazards model, the investigators found that the presence of asymptotic prevalent HSV-2 infection conferred an adjusted hazard ratio for HIV infection of 2.14 (compared with no genital ulceration and negative results of serologic testing for HSV-2). Symptomatic prevalent HSV-2 infection conferred an adjusted hazard ratio of 5.06.In short, this demonstrated that individuals experiencing incident HSV-2 infections are at the greatest risk of HIV acquisition, compared with individuals not infected with HSV-2 or who have prevalent HSV-2 infection. The individuals with serologic evidence of recent incident HSV-2 infection had the highest HIV incidence, illustrating that recent infection with HSV-2 is independently associated with HIV acquisition [4].Dr. Balfour pointed out that some recent in vitro studies have helped to explain the association between HSV-2 and HIV [4]. First, some studies have demonstrated that HSV-2 infection may increase the risk of HIV acquisition through the influx of susceptible, host  cells to the infected area. Studies have also demonstrated that HSV-2 has the ability to enhance HIV replication. The investigators suggested that the elevated risk of HIV acquisition among individuals with exposure to recent incident HSV-2 may reflect a more vigorous immune response in individuals who are immunologically naive to HSV-2. Further studies examining the local immune response to incident HSV-2 infection may help explain the elevated risk of HIV acquisition that is associated with exposure to incident HSV-2 [4, 12].Here we predict the potential impact of HIV on the probability and the expected severity of HSV-2 outbreaks using a discrete event simulation model. We also focus on the joint dynamics of HIV and HSV-2 at the population level. The model is not for a specific country or nation, and our approach does not preclude the possibility of joint infections. This model is used to explore the impact of factors associated with co-infections on the prevalence of each of the two diseases. The possibility of HIV infections is incorporated within epidemiological frameworks that have been developed for the transmission dynamics of HSV-2. The enhanced deterministic system is used to carry out a qualitative study of the joint transmission dynamics of HIV and HSV-2. We use an epidemiological model to study the dynamics of co-infection of HIV and HSV-2. Although there is no cure for both HIV and HSV-2, but we desire to reduce the disease burden of co-infection. That is, how can we reduce the disease load of HIV and HSV-2 co- infection?In this study we propose a mathematical model for the joint dynamics of HIV and HSV-2 co-infections. Our model is given by a set of differential equations and the details of the co-infection are very complicated, yet, we have managed to model the effects of co-infections in a simple setting.This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces our co-infection model; Section 3 computes the disease-free equilibrium point; Section 4 computes the basic reproduction number for our co-infection model and the local stability of the disease-free equilibrium point; Section 5 calculate the global stability of disease-free equilibrium; Section 6 compute the endemic equilibrium point and its stability; Section 7 focuses on numerical and graphical analysis and Section 8 gives our results and conclusions.
 cells to the infected area. Studies have also demonstrated that HSV-2 has the ability to enhance HIV replication. The investigators suggested that the elevated risk of HIV acquisition among individuals with exposure to recent incident HSV-2 may reflect a more vigorous immune response in individuals who are immunologically naive to HSV-2. Further studies examining the local immune response to incident HSV-2 infection may help explain the elevated risk of HIV acquisition that is associated with exposure to incident HSV-2 [4, 12].Here we predict the potential impact of HIV on the probability and the expected severity of HSV-2 outbreaks using a discrete event simulation model. We also focus on the joint dynamics of HIV and HSV-2 at the population level. The model is not for a specific country or nation, and our approach does not preclude the possibility of joint infections. This model is used to explore the impact of factors associated with co-infections on the prevalence of each of the two diseases. The possibility of HIV infections is incorporated within epidemiological frameworks that have been developed for the transmission dynamics of HSV-2. The enhanced deterministic system is used to carry out a qualitative study of the joint transmission dynamics of HIV and HSV-2. We use an epidemiological model to study the dynamics of co-infection of HIV and HSV-2. Although there is no cure for both HIV and HSV-2, but we desire to reduce the disease burden of co-infection. That is, how can we reduce the disease load of HIV and HSV-2 co- infection?In this study we propose a mathematical model for the joint dynamics of HIV and HSV-2 co-infections. Our model is given by a set of differential equations and the details of the co-infection are very complicated, yet, we have managed to model the effects of co-infections in a simple setting.This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces our co-infection model; Section 3 computes the disease-free equilibrium point; Section 4 computes the basic reproduction number for our co-infection model and the local stability of the disease-free equilibrium point; Section 5 calculate the global stability of disease-free equilibrium; Section 6 compute the endemic equilibrium point and its stability; Section 7 focuses on numerical and graphical analysis and Section 8 gives our results and conclusions. is subdivided into ten mutually-exclusive compartments, namely susceptible (S(t)), exposed to HSV-2 but show no clinical symptoms of the disease (E(t)), HSV-2 infected individuals with clinical symptoms of HSV-2 (I(t)), infected individuals whose infection is quiescent (Q(t)), individuals who are HIV positive (H(t)), individuals having AIDS (A(t)), individuals who are exposed to HSV-2 and HIV positive
 is subdivided into ten mutually-exclusive compartments, namely susceptible (S(t)), exposed to HSV-2 but show no clinical symptoms of the disease (E(t)), HSV-2 infected individuals with clinical symptoms of HSV-2 (I(t)), infected individuals whose infection is quiescent (Q(t)), individuals who are HIV positive (H(t)), individuals having AIDS (A(t)), individuals who are exposed to HSV-2 and HIV positive  , Individuals infected with HSV-2 and HIV positive
, Individuals infected with HSV-2 and HIV positive  , Individuals infected with HSV-2 whose infection is quiescent and HIV positive
, Individuals infected with HSV-2 whose infection is quiescent and HIV positive  , individuals in the AIDS class having HSV-2
, individuals in the AIDS class having HSV-2  so that the total population at time t is given by
 so that the total population at time t is given by The susceptible population is increased by the recruitment of individuals (assumed susceptible) into the population at a rate
The susceptible population is increased by the recruitment of individuals (assumed susceptible) into the population at a rate  .Susceptible individuals acquire HSV-2 infection, following effective contact with people infected with HSV-2 only (i.e. those in the E, I and Q classes) at a rate
.Susceptible individuals acquire HSV-2 infection, following effective contact with people infected with HSV-2 only (i.e. those in the E, I and Q classes) at a rate  , where
, where Here
Here  is the transmission rate for HSV-2 and the modification parameter
 is the transmission rate for HSV-2 and the modification parameter  accounts for the assumed reduction of infectivity of infectious individuals in the quiescent class. It is assumed that, the infectious individuals of quiescent state are less infectious than active HSV-2 infected individuals because of their assumed reduced viral load. The parameter
 accounts for the assumed reduction of infectivity of infectious individuals in the quiescent class. It is assumed that, the infectious individuals of quiescent state are less infectious than active HSV-2 infected individuals because of their assumed reduced viral load. The parameter  , indicates that an individuals with HIV and infected HSV-2 is more infectious compared with an individual with HIV and quiescent HSV-2.Similarly, the susceptible individuals acquire HIV at a rate
, indicates that an individuals with HIV and infected HSV-2 is more infectious compared with an individual with HIV and quiescent HSV-2.Similarly, the susceptible individuals acquire HIV at a rate  , where
, where Here
Here  is the transmission rate for HIV and the modification parameter
 is the transmission rate for HIV and the modification parameter  , indicates that an individual with HSV-2 and AIDS is more infectious then an individual’s having HIV and quiescent HSV-2. Combining all the aforementioned assumptions and definitions, the model becomes:
, indicates that an individual with HSV-2 and AIDS is more infectious then an individual’s having HIV and quiescent HSV-2. Combining all the aforementioned assumptions and definitions, the model becomes: Where
Where 
 and define the "diseased" classes that are either exposed or infectious. Thus we can construct the following two lemmas. Lemma 1: For all equilibrium points on
 and define the "diseased" classes that are either exposed or infectious. Thus we can construct the following two lemmas. Lemma 1: For all equilibrium points on  
  The positive DFE for the model (1) is
The positive DFE for the model (1) is  .Lemma 2: The model (1) has exactly a DFE and the DFE point is
.Lemma 2: The model (1) has exactly a DFE and the DFE point is  .Proof: The proof of the lemma requires that we show that the DFE is the only equilibrium point of (1) on
.Proof: The proof of the lemma requires that we show that the DFE is the only equilibrium point of (1) on  . Substituting
. Substituting  into (1) shows all derivatives equal to zero; hence DFE is an equilibrium point. From above lemma, the only equilibrium point for
 into (1) shows all derivatives equal to zero; hence DFE is an equilibrium point. From above lemma, the only equilibrium point for  is
 is  and the only equilibrium point for
 and the only equilibrium point for  is
 is  . Thus the only equilibrium point for
. Thus the only equilibrium point for  is DFE point [2].
 is DFE point [2].  . The basic reproduction number is defined as the expected number of secondary infections produced by an index case in a completely susceptible population. The associated non-negative matrix F, for the new infection terms, and the non-singular M-matrix, V, for the remaining transfer terms, are given, respectively, by
. The basic reproduction number is defined as the expected number of secondary infections produced by an index case in a completely susceptible population. The associated non-negative matrix F, for the new infection terms, and the non-singular M-matrix, V, for the remaining transfer terms, are given, respectively, by Where
Where The basic reproduction number
The basic reproduction number  is the spectral radius of the matrix
  is the spectral radius of the matrix  . The Eigen values   of the matrix
. The Eigen values   of the matrix  are
 are
 Thus we have the following lemma.Lemma 3. The disease-free equilibrium
Thus we have the following lemma.Lemma 3. The disease-free equilibrium  of the model (1) is locally asymptotically stable whenever
 of the model (1) is locally asymptotically stable whenever  and unstable
 and unstable  .
. Here
Here  and so the conditions are not met. So
 and so the conditions are not met. So  may or may not be globally asymptotically stable when
 may or may not be globally asymptotically stable when  .
. 
 
 so that
 so that Now the model (1) can be rewritten as
Now the model (1) can be rewritten as Where
Where 
 as
as Where
Where  and
  and The Jacobean of the system (2) is
     The Jacobean of the system (2) is Where
Where  To analyse the dynamics of (2), we compute the Eigen values of the Jacobean of (2) at the disease free equilibrium (DFE). It can be shown that this Jacobean has a right eigenvector given by:
To analyse the dynamics of (2), we compute the Eigen values of the Jacobean of (2) at the disease free equilibrium (DFE). It can be shown that this Jacobean has a right eigenvector given by: Where,
Where, 
 And the left eigenvectors are given by
And the left eigenvectors are given by  , where
, where  Now using (2) we have:
Now using (2) we have: and
and 
| 
 | 
| 
 | 
 when
 when where
 where  and
and  Theorem 1. The model (1) has a unique endemic equilibrium which is locally asymptotically stable when
Theorem 1. The model (1) has a unique endemic equilibrium which is locally asymptotically stable when  and unstable when
 and unstable when 
 is bigger than the backward transmission rate,
 is bigger than the backward transmission rate,  , the infected population as well as the disease prevalence decreases, which is expected. On the other hand if the backward transmission rate
, the infected population as well as the disease prevalence decreases, which is expected. On the other hand if the backward transmission rate  is bigger than the forward transmission rate,
 is bigger than the forward transmission rate,  , then the infected population as well as the disease prevalence increases, which also is expected.From figures (3) and (4), it is monitored that if we increase the value of
, then the infected population as well as the disease prevalence increases, which also is expected.From figures (3) and (4), it is monitored that if we increase the value of  , then the value of
, then the value of  also increases. Hence the number of infected population also increases. Here
 also increases. Hence the number of infected population also increases. Here  is the modification parameter which indicates the infectiousness of the classes
 is the modification parameter which indicates the infectiousness of the classes  and
 and  .Figure (5) (time series plot of co-infection) indicates that, the number of total infected population increases whenever
.Figure (5) (time series plot of co-infection) indicates that, the number of total infected population increases whenever  Figure (6) (time series plot of co-infection) indicates that, the number of total infected population increases whenever
Figure (6) (time series plot of co-infection) indicates that, the number of total infected population increases whenever  .Figure (7) (time series plot of HIV-infection) indicates that, the number of total infected population decreases whenever
.Figure (7) (time series plot of HIV-infection) indicates that, the number of total infected population decreases whenever  and otherwise increases (Fig. 8).Figure (9) and Figure (10) (time series plot of HSV-2 infection) indicates that, the number of total infected population decreases whenever
 and otherwise increases (Fig. 8).Figure (9) and Figure (10) (time series plot of HSV-2 infection) indicates that, the number of total infected population decreases whenever  and increases whenever
 and increases whenever 
|  | Figure 1.  Total infection for model (1) with different values of  and  where   | 
|  | Figure 2.  The prevalence as a function of time for model (1) with different values of  and  where  | 
|  | Figure 3.  Total infection as a function of time for model (1) with different values of  where   | 
|  | Figure 4.  The prevalence as a function of time for model (1) with different values of  where  | 
|  | Figure 5. Time series plot of the co infection for model (1) when R0 = 1.2499 | 
|  | Figure 6. Time series plot of co-infection for model (1) when R0 = 0.9750 | 
|  | Figure 7. Time series plot of HIV infection for model (1) when R0 = 0.9750 | 
|  | Figure 8. Time series plot of HIV infection for model (1) when R0 = 1.2499 | 
|  | Figure 9. Time series plot of HSV-2 infection for model (1) when R0 = 0.9750 | 
|  | Figure 10. Time series plot of HSV-2 infection for model (1) when R0 = 1.2499 | 
 and
 and  , which are the forward transmission rate from
, which are the forward transmission rate from   to
 to  class of HSV-2 progression in individuals and the backward transmission rate from
 class of HSV-2 progression in individuals and the backward transmission rate from  to
 to  class of HSV-2 . It is mentioned that, if
 class of HSV-2 . It is mentioned that, if  is bigger than
 is bigger than  , the infected population as well as the disease prevalence decreases. On the other hand, if
, the infected population as well as the disease prevalence decreases. On the other hand, if  is bigger than
 is bigger than  , then the infected population as well as the disease prevalence increases. This suggests that
, then the infected population as well as the disease prevalence increases. This suggests that  , and in some cases,
, and in some cases,  . Our numerical studies indicate that only in certain cases, this factor may play an important role for explaining the effect of HSV-2 epidemics on the increased or decreased prevalence level of HIV. Numerical simulations suggest that the individual experiencing incident HSV-2 infections are at a high risk of HIV acquisition compared to the individuals who are not infected with HSV-2 or who have prevalent HSV-2 infection. Thus the numerical simulation suggests that the reduction of the effective contact rate of HSV-2 can reduce the disease burden of co-infection. After controlling the transfer rate from HIV class to the AIDS class disease elimination is feasible. Maintaining the transfer rate from the HSV-2 exposed class to the HSV-2 infected class disease control is also feasible.
. Our numerical studies indicate that only in certain cases, this factor may play an important role for explaining the effect of HSV-2 epidemics on the increased or decreased prevalence level of HIV. Numerical simulations suggest that the individual experiencing incident HSV-2 infections are at a high risk of HIV acquisition compared to the individuals who are not infected with HSV-2 or who have prevalent HSV-2 infection. Thus the numerical simulation suggests that the reduction of the effective contact rate of HSV-2 can reduce the disease burden of co-infection. After controlling the transfer rate from HIV class to the AIDS class disease elimination is feasible. Maintaining the transfer rate from the HSV-2 exposed class to the HSV-2 infected class disease control is also feasible. and
 and  , the last two parameters indicates transfer rate between HIV and HSV-2 classes and modification parameter.
, the last two parameters indicates transfer rate between HIV and HSV-2 classes and modification parameter.  of HSV-2 can reduce the disease burden of co-infection.II. Controlling the transfer rate
 of HSV-2 can reduce the disease burden of co-infection.II. Controlling the transfer rate  from HIV class to the AIDS class disease elimination is feasible.III. Controlling the transfer rate
 from HIV class to the AIDS class disease elimination is feasible.III. Controlling the transfer rate  from the HSV-2 exposed class (E) to the HSV- 2 infected class (I) disease controls is feasible.
 from the HSV-2 exposed class (E) to the HSV- 2 infected class (I) disease controls is feasible.