Noram I. Ramli1, T. A. Majid2, F. A. Wan Chik1, M. K. A. Muhammad1, S. A. Che Deraman1
1Phd Candidates, School of Civil Engineering, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Nibong Tebal, Malaysia
2Coordinator Disaster Research Nexus, School of Civil Engineering, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Nibong Tebal, Malaysia
Correspondence to: Noram I. Ramli, Phd Candidates, School of Civil Engineering, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Nibong Tebal, Malaysia.
Email: | |
Copyright © 2014 Scientific & Academic Publishing. All Rights Reserved.
Abstract
Roof collapse due to wind load impact on roof sheeting during thunderstorm event was reported by media. In most cases, failure of roof sheeting based on two points, either on material roof sheeting or at connection of roof sheeting. It was observed that the most failure of roof sheeting is likely occurred for non-engineered building. Base on MS 1553:2002 wind load for building structure, structural elements should be able to resist wind speed up to 32.5 m/s. Therefore this study is conducted to identify the possibility of the pull-through failure of nail connection with Corrugated Galvanized Iron (CGI) roof sheeting for non-engineered buildings. This study is focus on the connection between roof sheet metal and nail connection with various spacing between the connections. Finite Element Method was used in this study to analyse and identify the load distribution. From the result it shows that the maximum spacing of nail connection is 480 mm to resist the wind load recommended by MS 1553:2002. From the result it can be concluded that as the spacing of connection increases the failure of CGI metal roof also increases.
Keywords:
Corrugated Galvanised Iron, Wind Storm, Rural Roofing
Cite this paper: Noram I. Ramli, T. A. Majid, F. A. Wan Chik, M. K. A. Muhammad, S. A. Che Deraman, Assessment of Pull-through Failure of Nail Connection for Rural Roofing System under Wind Load in Malaysia, Journal of Civil Engineering Research, Vol. 4 No. 3A, 2014, pp. 135-137. doi: 10.5923/c.jce.201402.23.
1. Introduction
The rapidly increase in numbers of damage due to wind-related disaster events over the last few years in Malaysia has created the awareness among the Malaysian society. In order to enhance the resistance of the building structure to withstand wind storms, further understanding on characteristic of wind - structure interaction is needed. Malaysia is located near the equator. In general, the wind climate is dominated by the two monsoon seasons and the inter-monsoon thunderstorms. The north-eastern monsoon blows from December to March, usually accompanied by heavy rains. Around June to September, wind blows in the south-western monsoon which is slightly tranquil. Thunderstorms frequently occur during the inter-monsoon periods. Although thunderstorms are localized phenomena, they often produce significant strong and gusty surface winds. These winds from thunderstorms are relatively stronger and more turbulent than those of monsoon winds. [3] Unlike in cyclone prone region, the thunderstorms in Malaysia occurs in micro scale [4]. Despite their small size and short duration of thunderstorm which is about 15 to 30 minutes, many damages has been reported in Newspapers. From the previous study, roof was the most damaging components due to wind storm [5].
2. Failure in Rural Roofing System
2.1. Malaysia Climate
Malaysia is a country located near the equator. It is equally important to know the flow pattern of wind across Malaysia is dominated by two major monsoons. The characteristic features of the climate of Malaysia are uniform temperature, high humidity and copious rainfall and they arise mainly from the maritime exposure of the country. The climate in this country is almost the same throughout the year. Though the wind over the country is generally light and variable, however there are some uniform periodic changes in the wind flow patterns across Malaysia. Flow pattern of wind system across Malaysia is dominated by two major monsoons. I. Southeast monsoon flow from mid-April until September. II. Northwest monsoon flow from early November until March.During the transition of two major monsoons, there are two shorter inter monsoon seasons. These two monsoons are transition between two major monsoons. In this transition monsoon, many thunderstorm events occur.
2.2. Rural Roofing Failure
Numbers study or research on the wind load effect on the roof structure has been conducted overseas but very few towards Malaysian environment in Malaysia [6-9], (Tamura, et al., 2001, 2009, 2010; Uematsu and Isyumov, 1999). Most of the rural houses are considered as non-engineered structures. Corrugated Galvanized Iron (CGI) sheet metal is commonly used in rural house roofing system. However there are no specific guidance on how the sheet zinc metal are assemble. CGI sheet metal frequently experienced a pull-through failure during the thunderstorm due to uplift forces. According to Mahaarachchi & Mahendran [9] from the field and laboratory investigations have shown that damage of steel roofs has often occurred due to the failures of their connections. From the previous study, a single nail connection can be with stand up to 0.71 kN [10]. In this study, CGI sheet metal was examined under the variation wind load. SAP 2000 software was used to analyse the wind load effect of CGI sheet metal. This study focus on the effect of nail connection spacingson CGI sheet metal until failure. The usual CGI sheet metal and nail that widely used in Malaysia is shown in Fig 1a and Fig 1b. In this study the CGI sheet metal model are examined with various wind speed and spacing of nail connections. | Figure 1a. CGI Sheet Metal |
| Figure 1b. Nail |
2.3. Equivalent Static Wind Load
In this study Equivalent Static Wind Load (ESWL) are been considered. Newton first law says that force, F can be calculated from mass and acceleration as follows. | (1) |
Where, m (mass) is equal to volume x density (ρ) and a, acceleration is equal to changing wind speed over an interval of time. From equation 1 force can be calculated, equation 2 also relates between wind speed and force. Winds have its own density and the acceleration can be calculated by measuring the wind speed changes within a specified interval of time. Another equation introduced by Bernoulli give more accurate assumption in calculation of static wind load. | (2) |
Where p is sum of static pressure, ρ is air density and V is velocity. This equation is called hyrodynamica, which specifies that the sum of static pressure, p and the velocity pressure, 0.5ρVs2 is constant along streamline. From equation 2 design wind speed pressure can be measured by: | (3) |
Equation 3 has been used until now as a guideline to calculate static pressure from basic wind speed for all major codes. It been also adopted in ISO 4354 as a guideline for drafting national codes of practice.
2.4. Result and Discussion
Table 1 shows, the value of force of each single point of nail connection for various spacing between nail connections. It clearly shows that as the distance between the connection increases, the force acting on each nail connection increases. From previous study [10] the maximum load before the pull through failure is identify at 0.7 kN. By using interpolation the 0.7 kN force will be estimated occur at the spacing between the nail connection of 480 mm. Consequently, the risk of pull through failure will occur if the spacing is greater than a 480 mm.Table 1. Pull Through Force per Connection |
| |
|
2.5. Conclusions
From this study, it can be concluded that the spacing of the connection are very important in order to resist wind load. By increasing the distance between the nail connections will affect the performance of the CGI sheet metal roofing. Base on MS 1553:2002 the minimum wind load design is 0.65kN/m2. Hence, the nail connection should not be allowed greater than 480 mm in distance to complying the minimum wind load recommended by MS1553:2002.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The research team thanks Universiti Sains Malaysia for the financial support from the Delivering Excellence Grant.
References
[1] | T.A. Majid, Noram I. Ramli, M.I. Ali, M, Syamsyul H. Saad, M. Hashim, I. Zakaria Malaysia Country Report 2010 APEC Wind Engineering Workshop, Gangneung Korea, 2010. |
[2] | Wan Chik, F.A, Ramli, N.I, Muhammad M.K.A, Majid, T.A, Amirul Hafiz, A Study on rural roofing system due to strong wind in Northern Peninsular Malaysia, The Eighth Asia-Pacific Conference on Wind Engineering, December 10-14, 2013, Chennai, India. |
[3] | Choi, E.C.C, Extreme wind characteristics over Singapore - An area in the equatorial belt, Journal of Wind Engineeringand Industrial Aerodynamics Volume 83, November 1999, Pages 61-69. |
[4] | Yusoff A, “A study on the characteristics of thunderstorm at Telekom Malaysia communication center, Seberang Jaya, Penang”., MSc Dissertation, School of Civil Engineering, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 2005. |
[5] | Tamura, Y., Kikuchi, H. and Hibi K., (2001), Extreme wind pressure distributions on low-rise building models, Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, pp 1 – 2, 1365 – 1366. |
[6] | Tamura, Y. Wind induced damage to buildings and disaster risk reduction, Proceedings of the APCWE-VII, 2009 Taipei, Taiwan. |
[7] | Tamura, Y. and S. Cao. Climate change wind-related disaster risk reduction. Proceedings of the 2010 APEC-WW and IG-WRDRR joint workshop wind-related disaster risk reduction (WRDRR) activities in Asia-Pacific region and cooperative actions. 2010 Korea. |
[8] | Uematsu, Y. and Isyumov, N., (1999), Wind pressures acting on the roof and wall edges of a low-rise building Part 4 Review of previous papers, Journal of Wind Engineering, JAWE,(78),(1999),13-27. |
[9] | Mahaarachi Dhammika & Mahendran A strain criterion for pull-through failures in crest-fixed steel claddings. Engineering Structures, 31(2), 2009 pp. 498-506. |
[10] | Lee Sid Hwa, Failure of roof structrure due to wind load. Master Project, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 2008. |
[11] | MS 1553:2002 “Malaysia Standard Code of Practise on Wind Loading for Building”, Department of Standards Malaysia, 2002. |